Info & Tips

Why Guide Dogs Are Not for All Visually Impaired People

When people think of braille, they assume all blind and visually impaired people read it. However, that is only sometimes the case because some people with vision loss might read large print with magnification or use an audio format. The same logic is sometimes applied to guide dogs. If a person is blind or visually impaired, it’s assumed that they should travel with a guide dog. The assumption is that these well-trained animals will provide the best mode of travel and mobility.

We published a previous post last year about beginning the process of using a guide dog. This experience can be rewarding for blind and visually impaired guide dog users.

However, before you commit to a guide dog, it is essential to consider your options carefully. Guide dogs for the blind make great companions and guides but require time, energy, and training. Plus, one must look at their home and work environment to be sure a guide dog would fit in that space. Another thing to consider is one’s overall physical and mental health. In honor of National Guide Dog Month, let’s examine why guide dogs might not be a good fit for you.

A working animal, not a pet.

The first thing to understand about guide dogs is that they are working animals, not pets. Guide dogs undergo weeks of training. They must follow a special diet, feeding schedule, and daily grooming regimen. Regular exercise must be managed for weight stabilization. Your furry guide and companion will give you additional daily responsibilities.

Here are some questions to ask before considering guide dog training:

  1. Would I use a dog enough to keep its skills up?

  2. Am I willing to rearrange my schedule to care for a dog?

  3. Do I have the patience and energy to be responsible for a guide dog?

The bottom line: Using a guide dog is a commitment and sacrifice.

Unfavorable home environment

The home environment must be evaluated. Do you share a home with family or friends? Although guide dogs for the blind are trained to be around people, they are not guaranteed to fit smoothly into that living space. Also, other animals in the home might not get along with a guide dog. An additional thing to ponder is your lifestyle. Are you an active or sedentary type of person? Guide dogs have undergone training to assist their owners with travel and mobility. If the dog is inactive, they can lose some of that training.

Your physical health 

If you are disabled or have medical/health issues limiting your mobility, then a guide dog might not work. Guide dogs typically move faster, and if there is a physical disability or health concern, this can be difficult. Additionally, if you are providing care for a disabled or medically ill relative in your home, a guide dog might not be a good fit. Your family and their health must be taken into consideration. 

Financial responsibility

Using a guide dog involves additional expenses. Purchasing food, pet supplies, toys, and veterinarian care can influence having a dog. Assistance and/or tax deductions might curb the cost, but consider the financial impact on your budget.

Must be a self-advocate

Although the ADA protects those using guide dogs, people with vision loss must advocate for themselves. Hotels, local small businesses, restaurants, and ride-share services are examples of places where guide dog users have been denied services. You will need to know your legal rights and be willing to stand up for yourself when these situations arise.

A guide dog can be an excellent mobility aid and travel companion. However, it is important to consider all options carefully before committing. Guide dogs are one of many tools that can enhance independence. White canes and technology can also be great mobility aids.

Outlook Enrichment can help you determine the best plan for achieving your goals with vision loss. Though we do not train guide dogs, we can connect you to guide dog schools. We can also teach you about adaptive technology and other techniques to make traveling easier. We can work with you to ensure your decisions work best for you, with or without a guide dog. Contact us today to get started.

White person's right hand reading braille

Info & Tips

Vision Resource Coalition

Read More
Woman with long hair with her back to the camera, holding her hands up as a heart.

Info & Tips

Emotional Well-Being

Read More

Info & Tips

Amazon Shopping Tips

Read More
See All Resources